Influence of Interorganizational Coordination on Lifecycle Design Decision Making: Comparative Case Study of Public–Private Partnership Highway Projects
Publication: Journal of Management in Engineering
Volume 34, Issue 5
Abstract
Organizational structures in public-private partnerships (P3s) have the potential to decrease fragmentation and increase collaboration between key project-team stakeholders across the lifecycle phases of a project. These outcomes, in turn, also enhance the realization of an improved lifecycle design. In this exploratory study, the interorganizational coordination of three recent U.S. P3s was analyzed and the influences of the coordination on the lifecycle design decision-making processes were compared. For each of the three P3 projects, the authors conducted interviews with key project team members and collected project documentation, and these data were then analyzed to explore lifecycle design decision-making processes for each project. The empirical findings show how interorganizational coordination mechanisms influence the lifecycle design decision-making processes in P3s. The findings also show the ways that the coordination mechanisms resulted in improved or inhibited lifecycle design decision-making according to differences in the intended and actual implementation. As coordination mechanisms diminished, particularly iterative and over-the-shoulder design processes, lifecycle design effectiveness decreased. Conversely, effective implementation of key coordination mechanisms, such as a single point of contact and over-the-shoulder design reviews by downstream team members, improved lifecycle design processes. Ultimately, this study extends the growing body of knowledge for understanding the influence of P3 organizational structures.
Get full access to this article
View all available purchase options and get full access to this article.
Acknowledgments
The authors thank all case study participants across the three projects studied who volunteered their time for this study. Their undisrupted attention, willingness to talk with the research team, and guidance on locating appropriate project documentation during the data collection period was invaluable.
References
Antillon, E. I., Molenaar, K. R., and Javernick-Will, A. (2017). “Evaluating the effect of contract timing on lifecycle-design innovation in public–private partnerships: Comparative case study of highway projects.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage., 05016023.
Baker, G., Gibbons, R., and Murphy, K. J. (2002). “Relational contracts and the theory of the firm.” Q. J. Econ., 117(1), 39–84.
Barlow, J., and Köberle-Gaiser, M. (2008). “The private finance initiative, project form and design innovation: The UK's hospitals programme.” Res. Policy, 37(8), 1392–1402.
Barlow, J., Roehrich, J., and Wright, S. (2013). “Europe sees mixed results from public-private partnerships for building and managing health care facilities and services.” Health Affairs, 32(1),146–154.
Blanc-Brude, F., Goldsmith, H., and Välilä, T. (2009). “A comparison of construction contract prices for traditionally procured roads and public–private partnerships.” Rev. Ind. Organiz., 35.
Brinkerhoff, D. W., and Brinkerhoff, J. M. (2011). “Public–private partnerships: Perspectives on purposes, publicness, and good governance.” Publ. Adm. Dev., 31(1), 2–14.
Buxbaum, J. N., and Ortiz, I. N. (2009). “Public-sector decision making for public-private partnerships: A synthesis of highway practice.” NCHRP Synthesis 391, National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine; Transportation Research Board, Washington, DC.
Caldwell, N. D., Roehrich, J. K., and Davies, A. C. (2009). “Procuring complex performance in construction: London Heathrow Terminal 5 and a private finance initiative hospital.” J. Purchasing Supply Manage., 15(3), 178–186.
Caldwell, N. D., Roehrich, J. K., and George, G. (2017). “Social value creation and relational coordination in public‐private collaborations.” J. Manage. Stud., 54(6), 906–928.
Caniëls, M. C. J., Gelderman, C. J., and Vermeulen, N. P. (2012). “The interplay of governance mechanisms in complex procurement projects.” J. Purchasing Supply Manage., 18(2), 113–121.
Cao, Z., and Lumineau, F. (2015). “Revisiting the interplay between contractual and relational governance: A qualitative and meta-analytic investigation.” J. Oper. Manage., 33-34(Jan), 15–42.
Clifton, C., and Duffield, C. F. (2006). “Improved PFI/PPP service outcomes through the integration of Alliance principles.” Int. J. Project Manage., 24, 573–586.
Coase, R. H. (1937). “The nature of the firm.” Economica, 4(16), 386–405.
Davies, A., and Salter, A. (2006). “Chapter 4: The great experiment: Public-Private partnerships and innovation in design, production, and operation of capital goods in the UK.” Flexibility and stability in the innovating economy, M. McKelvey and M. Holmén, eds., Oxford University Press, New York, 73–95.
Eggers, W. D., and Dovey, T. (2007). “Closing America’s infrastructure gap: The role of public-private partnerships.” Deloitte research study, Deloitte Services LP, Washington, DC.
Eisenhardt, K. M. (1989). “Building theories from case study research.” Acad. Manage. Rev., 14(4), 532–550.
Eisenhardt, K. M., and Graebner, M. E. (2007). “Theory building from cases: Opportunities and challenges.” Acad. Manage. J., 50(1), 25–32.
Fergusson, K. J., and Teicholz, P. M. (1993). “Impact of integration on industrial facility quality.” Stanford Univ., Stanford, CA.
FHWA. (2013). “P3 Defined.” 〈http://www.fhwa.dot.gov/ipd/p3/defined/index.htm〉 (Accessed: Nov. 2, 2017).
FHWA. (2017). “P3 Concessions in the US.” 〈http://www.fhwa.dot.gov/ipd/p3/resources/p3_concessions_map_newbuild.aspx〉 (Accessed: Nov. 2, 2017).
Fitzgerald, P. (2004). “Review of Partnerships Victoria provided infrastructure.” Final Rep. to the Treasurer, Growth Solutions Group, Melbourne, Australia.
Garvin, M. J., and Bosso, D. (2008). “Assessing the effectiveness of infrastructure public–private partnership programs and projects.” Public Works Manage. Policy, 13(2), 162–178.
Grimsey, D., and Lewis, M. K. (2007). Public private partnerships: the worldwide revolution in infrastructure provision and project finance, Edward Elgar, Camberley, U.K.
Grout, P. A. (1997). “The economics of the private finance initiative.” Oxford Rev. Econ. Policy, 13(4), 53–66.
Gulati, R. (1995). “Does familiarity breed trust? The implications of repeated ties for contractual choice in alliances.” Acad. Manage. J., 38(1), 85–112.
Guo, F., Chang-Richards, Y., Wilkinson, S., and Li, T. C. (2014). “Effects of project governance structures on the management of risks in major infrastructure projects: A comparative analysis.” Int. J. Project Manage., 32(5), 815–826.
Hall, D., Algiers, A., Lehtinen, T., Levitt, R. E., Li, C., and Padachuri, P. (2014). “The role of integrated project delivery elements in adoption of integral innovations.” EPOC 2014: Engineering Project Organizations Conf. Beyond Boundaries, Engineering Project Organization Society, 1–20.
Hart, O. (2003). “Incomplete contracts and public ownership: Remarks, and an application to public- private partnerships.” Econ. J., 113(486), 69–76.
Hartmann, A., Roehrich, J., Frederiksen, L., and Davies, A. (2014). “Procuring complex performance: The transition process in public infrastructure.” Int. J. Oper. Prod. Manage., 34(2), 174–194.
Hatem, D. J., and Gary, P. B., eds. (2013). Public-private partnerships: Opportunities and risks for consulting engineers, American Council of Engineering Companies, Washington, DC.
Hodge, G. A., and Greve, C. (2007). “Public-private partnerships: An international performance review.” Public Adm. Rev., 67(3), 545–558.
Ke, Y., Wang, S., Chan, A. P., and Cheung, E. (2009). “Research trend of public-private partnership in construction journals.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage., 1076–1086.
Koppenjan, J. F. M. (2005). “The formation of public‐private partnerships: Lessons from nine transport infrastructure projects in The Netherlands.” Public Adm., 83(1), 135–157.
Kwak, Y. H., Chih, Y., and Ibbs, C. W. (2009). “Towards a comprehensive understanding of public private partnerships for infrastructure development.” Calif. Manage. Rev., 51(2), 51–78.
Lehtinen, T. (2012). “Increasing integration in construction projects: A case study on a PPP project adopting BIM.” Proc., European Conf., Product and Process Modelling 2012, EWork and EBusiness in Architecture, Engineering and Construction, G. Gudnason and R. Scherer, eds., CRC, Boca Raton, FL, 439–446.
Lin, Y.-H., and Ho, S. P. (2013). “Impacts of governance structure strategies on the performance of construction joint ventures.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage., 304–311.
Miles, M. B., Huberman, A. M., and Saldaña, J. (2014). Qualitative data analysis: A methods sourcebook”. Sage, Thousand Oaks, CA.
Nvivo [Computer software]. QSR International, Melbourne, Australia.
Oppenheim, A. N. (1992). Questionnaire design, interviewing, and attitude measurement, Pinter, New York.
Osei-Kyei, R., and Chan, A. P. C. (2015). “Review of studies on the critical success factors for public–private partnership (PPP) projects from 1990 to 2013.” Int. J. Project Manage., 33(6), 1335–1346.
Paulson, B. C., Jr. (1976). “Designing to reduce construction costs.” J. Constr. Div., 102(4), 587–592.
Ping Ho, S., Levitt, R., Tsui, C. W., and Hsu, Y. (2015). “Opportunism-focused transaction cost analysis of public-private partnerships.” J. Manage. Eng., 04015007.
Poppo, L., and Zenger, T. (2002). “Do formal contracts and relational governance function as substitutes or complements?” Strategic Manage. J., 23(8), 707–725.
Public Works Financing. (2017). September 2017: Public works financing major projects database 9/17, Public Works Financing, Volume 329, (p. 9), Peterborough, NH.
Regimbal, J. J., Jr. (2012). “An examination of the Virginia Public-Private Transportation Act of 1995.” Fiscal Analytics, Charlottesville, VA.
Roehrich, J. K., Barlow, J., and Wright, S. (2013). “Delivering European healthcare infrastructure through public-private partnerships: The theory and practice of contracting and bundling.” Managing public-private strategic alliances, 1st ed., T. K. Das, ed., Information Age, Scottsdale, AZ.
Roehrich, J. K., and Caldwell, N. D. (2012). “Delivering integrated solutions in the public sector: The unbundling paradox.” Ind. Marketing Manage., 41(6), 995–1007.
Roehrich, J. K., and Lewis, M. A. (2010). “Towards a model of governance in complex (product–service) inter‐organizational systems.” Constr. Manage. Econ., 28(11), 1155–1164.
Roehrich, J. K., Lewis, M. A., and George, G. (2014). “Are public–private partnerships a healthy option? A systematic literature review.” Social Sci. Med., 113(Jul), 110–119.
Royce, W. W. (1970). “Managing the development of large software systems.” Proc., IEEE, WESCON, IEEE, New York, 1–9.
Ruuska, I., Ahola, T., Artto, K., Locatelli, G., and Mancini, M. (2011). “A new governance approach for multi-firm projects: Lessons from Olkiluoto 3 and Flamanville 3 nuclear power plant projects.” Int. J. Project Manage., 29(6), 647–660.
Saldaña, J. (2009). The coding manual for qualitative researchers, Sage, Thousand Oaks, CA.
Sheffer, D. A., and Levitt, R. E. (2010). “How industry structure retards diffusion of innovations in construction: Challenges and opportunities.” Working Paper 59, Collaboratory for Research on Global Projects, Stanford Univ., Stanford, CA.
Sheffer, D. A., and Levitt, R. E. (2012). “Fragmentation inhibits innovation: Overcoming professional and trade lock-in.” CRGP Working paper 0069, Collaboratory for Research on Global Projects, Stanford Univ., Stanford, CA.
Siering, J., and Svensson, A., (2012). “Managing external stakeholder relationships in PPP Projects–A multidimensional approach.” Technical Rep. No. 2012:163, Chalmers Univ. of Technology, Göteborg, Sweden.
Spiller, P. T. (2008). “An institutional theory of public contracts: Regulatory implications.” NBER Working Paper 14152, National Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA.
Spradley, J. P. (1979). The ethnographic interview, Wadsworth, Belmont, CA.
Tang, L., Shen, Q., and Cheng, E. W. L. (2010). “A review of studies on public–private partnership projects in the construction industry.” Int. J. Project Manage., 28(7), 683–694.
Taylor, J. E., Dossick, C. S., and Garvin, M. (2011). “Meeting the burden of proof with case-study research.” J. Constr. Eng. Manage., 303–311.
Thomassen, M. (2011). “BIM & collaboration in the AEC industry BIM & collaboration in the AEC industry.” M.Sc. Thesis, Department of Mechanical and Manufacturing Engineering, Aalborg University, Aalborg, Denmark.
Too, E. G., and Weaver, P. (2014). “The management of project management: A conceptual framework for project governance.” Int. J. Project Manage., 32(18), 1382–1394.
Touran, A., Gransberg, D. D., Molenaar, K. R., Ghavamifar, K., Mason, D. J., and Fithian, L. A. (2009). “A guidebook for the evaluation of project delivery methods.” TCRP Rep. 131, Transportation Research Board, Washington, DC.
Turner, J. R., and Müller, R. (2004). “Communication and co-operation on projects between the project owner as principal and the project manager as agent.” Eur. Manage. J., 22(3), 327–336.
van Buiten, M., and Hartmann, A. (2015). “Asset management perspective on the duration of public-private partnership contracts: Cost-control trade-off?” J. Constr. Eng. Manage., 04014080.
van Marrewijk, A., Clegg, S. R., Pitsis, T. S., and Veenswijk, M. (2008). “Managing public–private megaprojects: Paradoxes, complexity, and project design.” International Journal of Project Management, 26(6), 591–600.
Weisert, C. (2003). “There’s no such thing as the waterfall approach! (and there never was).” Information Disciplines, Inc. 〈http://www.idinews.com/waterfall.html〉 (Accessed: Nov. 2, 2017).
Williamson, O. E. (1979). “Transaction-cost economics: The governance of contractual relations.” J. Law Econ., 22(2), 233–261.
Williamson, O. E. (1999). “Public and private bureaucracies: a transaction cost economics perspectives.” J. Law Econ. Organiz., 15(1), 306–342.
World Bank Group (2014). Public-private partnerships: Reference guide, Version 2.0, World Bank, Washington, DC.
Yescombe, E. (2007). Public–private partnerships: Principles of policy and finance, Butterworth-Heinemann, Oxford, U.K.
Yin, R. K. (2009). Case study research: Design and methods, 4th Ed., Sage, Thousand Oaks, CA.
Zhang, X., and Ali Soomro, M. (2016). “Failure path analysis with respect to private sector partners in transportation public-private partnerships.” J. Manage. Eng., 04015031.
Zheng, J., Roehrich, J. K., and Lewis, M. A. (2008). “The dynamics of contractual and relational governance: Evidence from long-term public–private procurement arrangements.” J. Purchasing Supply Manage., 14(1), 43–54.
Information & Authors
Information
Published In
Journal of Management in Engineering
Volume 34 • Issue 5 • September 2018
Copyright
© 2018 American Society of Civil Engineers.
History
Received: Jun 29, 2017
Accepted: Jan 19, 2018
Published online: May 2, 2018
Published in print: Sep 1, 2018
Discussion open until: Oct 2, 2018
Authors
Metrics & Citations
Metrics
Citations
Download citation
If you have the appropriate software installed, you can download article citation data to the citation manager of your choice. Simply select your manager software from the list below and click Download.